Comments: San Francisco, March 20, 2003 (Part I)

So far, only one thing that I remember significantly differently, and that is that I don't think the pipes were long enough to leave space between people's outstretched hands. My impression was that the demonstrators were holding hands _inside_ the pipes, and that there was only space if they dropped the hold.

One difference that age has made for me is that I found myself identifying strongly with the firemen (firepeople? I couldn't see their faces) cutting through the pipes; I _know_ how much they didn't want to cut off anyone's fingers. When I was 22, I think I would have figured that they didn't want to get sued, but I now know that the fear of injury was a big personal cost to (many of) them, as well as to the demonstrators.

Personally, I can't imagine letting someone run a circular saw that close to my arm when I could just take my arm out of the pipe and save the risk--but I'm impressed with the conviction of the protesters and the care of the firepeople, glad I was there to witness, and glad that no one lost any fingers (or any blood) in the process.

Posted by Debbie Notkin at March 21, 2003 02:49 PM

What I recall is that the chained demonstrators were either gripping or shackled to chains that ran through the tubes. I very definitely observed that after a section of tube was completely cut throught and pulled aside, there was chain in the middle that also needed to be cut.

Posted by Alan Bostick at March 21, 2003 03:07 PM